201. THE BEGINNING AND THE END

Written by Glen Morgan and James Wong
Directed by Thomas J. Wright
Original Air Date: September 19, 1997

printable version
(opens in new window)

 

Brief summary: In pursuit of the mysterious Polaroid Stalker who kidnapped his wife, Frank finds himself at odds with The Millennium Group and struggles to hold the darkness within himself at bay.

Rogue's Review: "It will never again be the same," Frank Black whispers in voiceover during the prologue -- a fitting statement as MILLENNIUM plunges into its second season, and resolves the circumstances of Catherine Black's abduction by the malevolent Polaroid Stalker.

The episode opens with the gripping encounter in SeaTac Airport between Catherine and the Stalker (1013 perennial fave Doug Hutchinson, who played the title role in the XF outing "Tooms" and the sinister Elroy-L in Morgan & Wong's first indie production, SPACE: ABOVE & BEYOND). Chilling stuff!

Unfortunately, things begin to slip soon afterward. The crux of the problem, as always, is time. The ep begs to be a two-parter, in order to more effectively tell the story of the Polaroid Stalker, his connection to the Millennium Group, and the Group's decision to bring Frank into the fold. We learn some intriguing new facts about Peter Watts, including the story of the dead baby in the water cooler -- the case that drove him from the Bureau to the Group -- but the disconnected nature of the sequence diminishes its impact.

"The Beginning and the End" seems, in fact, like a series of excerpts from a larger work. The introduction of Brian Roedecker (not his finest hour), the extended sequence where the Stalker torments Catherine with meandering Biblical passages (mixed with Dr. Seuss), the "search" montage where Frank hunts down his quarry -- there is a rushed quality to the episode that ruins the beauty of some of its individual moments.

Worse still, there are leaps in logic that the tale itself cannot justify. Despite all we learn over the coming season, it is NEVER adequately explained why Frank continues to tolerate the methods of the Group, when he knows full well that if they did not outright orchestrate the events of Catherine's abduction by the Stalker (a former Group candidate gone mad), they at least opted not to warn him of the danger, or take actions to prevent her kidnapping.

The Polaroid Stalker himself is a tragic waste. After a season of speculation over this strange, never-seen specter, we're treated to the mad brilliance of Hutchinson's performance for only one episode before he's killed off! We know he was sending the Polaroids even before MILLENNIUM began, back when Black was still with the FBI -- but no attempt is made to reconcile that fact. If the Stalker knew more, knew the importance of Frank's work or his role in the coming apocalypse... that knowledge died with him.

And what's up with the Group? The seesawing good guys/bad guys thing may add depth and excitement to THE X-FILES, but it only hinders the logic of this series. When Frank dismisses Peter's cautionary words and goes after the Stalker himself, Peter's shadowy superior says, "He's only doing what we should have done by now. Help him." So why, exactly, does the Group spend so many future episodes condemning Frank's subsequent behavior?

The worst offense is the way the Black family comes apart. Catherine condemns Frank's actions, telling him he's lost a part of himself by taking a life, and they go their separate ways. Absolutely unbelievable! The series would have been better served if Catherine had simply decided enough was enough -- his work, the Group, the darkness that has been introduced into their lives and their home... The groundwork had been laid for Catherine to simply leave until Frank made a choice between his work and his family.

But Morgan and Wong, in their first outing as MM's executive producers, decided to take an illogical route. Her life was put into mortal jeopardy, she had been led to believe this madman had murdered her child -- yet when Frank arrives and the Stalker attacks, actually STABBING him, Catherine is appalled that Frank defends himself and takes the killer's life with the killer's own weapon?! I didn't buy it at all.

The estrangement DOES set up the groundwork for the season to come, however. It's an unusual story choice -- one that ultimately gives us some of the finest MILLENNIUM outings to date. I only wish this introductory episode had devoted as much time to logic and credibility as it did to stacking the deck for the season to come.

Some interesting factoids: Peter's daughters are named Taylor, Erin and Chelsea... The scientific name of the split-tailed comet is "P1997 Vansen-West" -- Shane Vansen and Nathan West were the lead characters in S:AAB... The Polaroid Stalker also throws out an interesting bit of foreshadowing when he says, "The Mayans saw [the comet] just before a plague wiped out half their civilization." For viewers familiar with the way Season Two concludes, that's some chilling prophecy indeed. [Rating: 4/10]

   
   

 

   
     
   
     
 

reviews by Rick Smith (1996 - present) and website by Matt Asendorf (2004), property of Paper Street Productions